Linda Nagata: the blog at Hahví.net


The Butterfly Effect

November 20th, 2009

Nanowrimo is well underway. For those unfamiliar, this is a writing exercise, held in November, with the goal of producing a 50,000-word novel in a month. The idea, as I understand it, is to just write, without concern for the inner editor, letting the unconscious creative spark take over. You won’t have a publishable novel at the end of it, but you might have a good framework to build on, with some great scenes, and you will at least have something.

My daughter persuaded me to sign up for Nanowrimo last year. That lasted for about two hours and this year I refused to go near it. I’m not recommending against Nanowrimo. It’s just not the way I write.

There are writers who always write in the Nanowrimo style, pouring out chapter after chapter without pause or revision until they reach the end, and then going back to re-write it all later. And then there are writers like me who insist on a polished chapter 1 before going on to chapter 2, and if something in chapter 2 changes things, then of course one must go back to chapter 1 and revise accordingly. While I admit this is mostly personal style, for me there is also a logical reason for doing this—because naturally everything that happens in a given chapter is dependent on what happened, or what was introduced in prior chapters. So that when I do go back and change some plot thread at an earlier point in the story, the repercussions are always more than I initially hope. This is the writer’s version of the butterfly effect, and this re-write of The Wild is turning out to be a profound demonstration of it.

The idea behind this re-write was to change the opening to better set up the story, change some motivations to provide better conflict, and change some of the plot to do the same. But once those butterfly wings start stirring the air, the winds can get very erratic.

I had hoped to make big changes in certain sections while holding onto other parts—and significantly the last quarter of the book—pretty much “as is.” So of course I have wound up re-writing almost everything. Oh, I’ve preserved some scenes and lots of paragraphs, but I bet if I went through and highlighted new stuff versus old stuff (and no, I’m not obsessive enough to actually do this) it would probably be 70% new, even though it’s telling essentially the same story.

The really painful moments are when I am forced to dump favorite scenes because they no longer fit in.

But onward. I’ve figured out the major plot points and motivations for the next to last section and have even managed to recycle some of the more dramatic moments. Now to outline it, and then to write it. It’s still possible I could pull this off in a way that will require only minimal changes in the last section. That’s the goal, but I’m not making bets on it.

Posted on: Friday, November 20th, 2009 at 10:34 am
Categories: The Wild, Writing.

2 Responses to “The Butterfly Effect”

  1. Phillip Massebeau Says:

    Hi Linda,
    I haven’t been able to leave a comment in the last few months. I hope this one will go through.
    I sure would love to read “The Wild.” The first version, the second version or any part of it. I think your editors or someone works you too hard and you are looking for some kind of perfection before publishing. Those publishers probably don’t even read Sci-fi and judge it from their own personal preferences. Your fans will love anything you produce even it is written nanowrimo style.

  2. Linda Says:

    Hi Phil–Thanks for checking in with me! I should check the viability of the comments module every time WordPress gets an upgrade; I just didn’t think about it this past time.

    At any rate, I do need to get a certain level of enthusiasm from readers before I feel that a book is ready to publish. Hopefully this iteration of The Wild will get to that point! And hopefully it will get there before too much more time goes by.